Children's Literature Reviews
Item 1 of 1

Punished!
by David Lubar.
Plain City, OH : Darby Creek Pub., c2006.
96 p. ; 20 cm.

Annotations:

Logan and his friend Benedict are playing tag in the library. Logan gets caught when he runs into a mysterious man. When Logan doesn't apologize sincerely, the mysterious gentleman punishes him by causing him to speak in puns. Only finding seven examples each of oxymorons, anagrams and palindromes within the time limits will return Logan to normal.
Ages 9 and up.

Best Books:

School Library Journal Book Review Stars, May 2006 ; Cahners; United States

Awards, Honors, Prizes:

Golden Archer Award, 2007-2008 Nominee Intermediate Wisconsin
Keystone to Reading Book Award, 2009 Winner Intermediate Pennsylvania

State and Provincial Reading Lists:

Cochecho Readers' Award, 2007-2008 ; Nominee; New Hampshire
Flicker Tale Children's Book Award, 2009-2010 ; Nominee; Intermediate Books; North Dakota
Great Stone Face Award, 2007-2008 ; Nominee; New Hampshire
Horned Toad Tales, 2007 ; Nominee; Texas
Kentucky Bluegrass Award, 2008 ; Nominee; Grade 3-5; Kentucky
Keystone to Reading Book Award, 2009 ; Nominee; Intermediate; Pennsylvania
Massachusetts Children's Book Award, 2008-2009 ; Master List; Massachusetts
Maud Hart Lovelace Book Award, 2008-2009 ; Nominee; Grades 3-5; Minnesota
Nene Award, 2008 ; Nominee; Hawaii
Nene Award, 2009 ; Nominee; Hawaii
Nene Award, 2010 ; Nominee; Hawaii
Nevada Young Readers' Award, 2008 ; Nominee; Young Reader; Nevada
Sunshine State Young Reader's Award, 2009-2010 ; Nominee; Grades 3-5; Florida
Virginia Readers' Choice Award, 2008-2009 ; Nominee; Elementary; Virginia
Volunteer State Book Award, 2008-2009 ; Nominee; Grades 4-6; Tennessee
William Allen White Children's Book Award, 2008-2009 ; Master List; Grades 3-5; Kansas
Wisconsin Battle of the Books, 2007-2008 ; Elementary Division; Wisconsin
Wisconsin Battle of the Books, 2007-2008 ; Middle Level; Wisconsin

Reading Measurement Programs:


Accelerated Reader
Interest Level Lower Grade
Book Level 3.6
Accelerated Reader Points 1
Accelerated Vocabulary

Lexile, MetaMetrics, Inc.
Lexile Measure 540

Reading Counts-Scholastic
Interest Level 3-5
Reading Level 4
Title Point Value 5
Lexile Measure 540

Reviews:

Gillian Engberg (Booklist, May 1, 2006 (Vol. 102, No. 17))
Wordplay is at the heart of this funny, surreal adventure in which even the title is a pun. While roughhousing at the library with his friend Benedict, Logan literally runs into an elderly patron, who, as a punishment, saddles Logan with an unusual curse: everything he tries to say comes out as a pun. After a day in which even his dog groans at his tedious jokes, Logan is desperate to lift the curse. The cure, according to the elderly spell caster, involves more wordplay: Logan must hunt down examples of oxymorons, anagrams, and palindromes. Younger kids may need help with a few of the more sophisticated puns ("I was jest doing wit you asked"), but with an appealing mix of magic and silliness, Lubar captures Logan's frustrations when he is unjustly accused of disobedience, his urgency to solve his dilemma, and the linguistic fun: "I realized I had two palindromes living at home . . . Mom and Dad." Teachers will find plenty of uses for this. Category: Books for Middle Readers--Fiction. 2006, Darby Creek, $15.95. Gr. 4-7.

Anita Barnes Lowen (Children's Literature)
Logan knows he shouldn’t play tag in the library, but he has no choice. It’s totally impossible to sit still once you’re tagged. And when his friend, Benedict starts a game of tag, Logan chases him until he runs into big trouble in the shape of an old guy--an old guy who says Logan needs to be punished. Now whenever Logan opens his mouth, an unintended pun comes out. After one or two groaners, almost no one finds this funny, but Logan can’t stop. His best friend, Benedict, is angry. His parents think he’s silly. His teacher has sent him to the principal’s office. The only person who thinks he’s funny is his little sister. Is there anyway to remove this punishment? Yes, says the old guy. All Logan needs to do is find seven oxymorons, seven anagrams, and seven palindromes. But can he do it before time runs out? This funny and fast read would be a wonderful addition to any language arts curriculum. 2006, Darby Creek Publishing, $15.95. Ages 8 to 10.

Nancy Garhan Attebury (Children's Literature)
What a fantastic way to teach language arts! Early readers will find that the story is strong and that they can learn “school stuff” in a fun way. The tale is simple and understandable. In it, Logan encounters Professor Robert Wordsworth and learns about “word” magic when he and his busy friend Benedict are racing around the inside of the library. The professor blows magic dust from the cover of a book into Logan’s face. From there on out, Logan is being “punished.” Ridiculously entertaining puns spill out of his mouth whenever he tries to comment and ask questions. Grown-ups and kids moan and groan in answer to his puns. Wordsworth agrees to cure Logan only if he finds some oxymorons and anagrams in his everyday life. Logan sets out to find the words and in so doing, he presents the reader with perfect examples of the word forms. The author has the ability to make the characters real, thereby allowing children this age to identify with Logan and even Benedict. This unique tale is sure to encourage even the most reluctant reader and to make teaching language arts much easier for teachers. It is best for a reader to read the book instead of having it read to them. It helps to see the words in sentences packed with a pun. Add several copies to a classroom or library so many students can read them for language arts. 2006, Darby Creek Publishing, $15.95. Ages 9 to 12.

Subjects:

Boys Fiction.
Friendship Fiction.
Word games Fiction.
Boys Juvenile fiction.
Friendship Juvenile fiction.
Word games Juvenile fiction.

Reproduction Number:

Darby Creek Publishing www.darbycreekpublishing.com
Junior Library Guild http://www.juniorlibraryguild.com
LanguageCall NumberLCCNDewey DecimalISBN/ISSN
English (eng) MLCS 2006/45643 (P)
2006297970 [Fic]
1581960425 (hardcover)
9781581960426
View the WorldCat Record for this item.